Introduction
Extract questions are a fundamental aspect of AS History examinations, designed to assess your ability to critically analyse historical sources. These questions go beyond identifying facts; they require you to delve into the main arguments presented in the extracts, assess their validity, and compare different perspectives. In this blog post, we’ll provide you with five essential tips to excel in answering AS History Extract questions.
1. Identify and Analyse the Main and Sub-Arguments: The primary purpose of tackling an Extract question is to identify the main argument and any sub-arguments within each extract. Remember, it’s not about determining whether the content is true or false; it’s about comprehending the author’s overarching message. To do this effectively, focus on the key themes, ideas, and viewpoints presented. Break down the argument into its main components, which will guide you through the subsequent steps.
2. Select Relevant Examples of Evidence: Once you’ve extracted the arguments, support or challenge them with concrete examples from your knowledge. These examples should be factual and directly linked to the author’s point. For instance, if the extract discusses the impact of industrialisation, mention specific industries, statistics or events. Using factual evidence strengthens your analysis and demonstrates your understanding of the extract’s content.
3. Explain How Evidence Supports or Challenges the Argument: To demonstrate a thorough grasp of the extract, explain how the evidence you’ve chosen either supports or challenges the argument. This step requires you to connect the dots between the argument and the evidence. Discuss why certain examples reinforce the author’s point, or why others might weaken it. Use evaluative language, such as ‘convincing,’ ‘weakens,’ ‘undermines,’ etc., to provide a nuanced analysis of the relationship between the argument and evidence.
4. Utilise Evaluative Language: Evaluative language is your ally when dissecting extract arguments. Avoid terms like ‘true’ or ‘false,’ as they oversimplify the analytical process. Instead, employ language that reflects your critical evaluation, such as ‘persuasive,’ ‘compelling,’ ‘flawed’, ‘insightful,’ and ‘unconvincing.’ This vocabulary showcases your ability to assess historical arguments in a balanced and thoughtful manner.
5. Compare Extracts and Conclude: Outstanding answers in Extract questions go beyond individual analyses. As you work through the extracts, draw comparisons between them. Identify similarities, differences, contradictions, or complementary aspects in the arguments presented. Your conclusion should bring your analysis full circle. State which extract’s argument is the most convincing based on the evidence provided and the strength of the author’s reasoning. Justify your choice with reference to the analysis you’ve presented throughout your answer.
Conclusion
Mastering AS History Extract questions involves moving beyond surface-level comprehension and engaging in critical analysis. By following these five tips, you’ll be well-equipped to identify, assess, and compare arguments within extracts, while also supporting your evaluations with relevant evidence. Remember, it’s not about whether the content is ‘true’ or ‘false,’ but rather about your ability to dissect and evaluate historical viewpoints effectively. With practice, you’ll become adept at extracting the essence of historical arguments and presenting well-supported, balanced conclusions.
Teachers: if your centre wants some specific training on how to tackle AS or A level exam technique, then drop me a line TODAY. Use the contact link on the website.
Students: Want to understand more? Then contact me and ask for a 1-2-1 private tuition session TODAY. Use the contact link on the website.